Plant Proof - Plant Based Nutrition & Inspirational Stories

Episode #343. Vegan vs. carnivore – which diet stands up to the science? Join me in this fiery debate to find out. Hosted by Ellen Fisher, this thought-provoking episode pits me, Simon Hill, against Dr Robert Kiltz, a leading voice in the carnivore and keto movements. Together, we explore opposing perspectives on nutrition, from the hierarchy of evidence to the health implications of plant-based and animal-based diets. Whether you’re vegan, carnivore, or somewhere in between, this conversation will challenge your views and help you make more informed decisions about your health and the planet. Specifically, we discuss: Introduction (00:00) Personal Health Journeys: How Diet Shapes Our Lives (02:20) Scientific Evidence vs. Personal Anecdotes: Finding the Truth (07:50) Nutritional Science and Its Impact on Public Health (16:51) Mechanisms and Metabolic Health (22:55) Why Experts Disagree: Conflicting Views on Diet and Health (30:16) Ansel Keys Revisited: The Fat vs. Sugar Debate in Nutrition (54:45) Ou